metallic flakes in oil!
#1
metallic flakes in oil!
I changed the oil again today in my 03' 4Runner and noticed a few small metallic flakes stuck to the drain plug. I've got almost 17K miles on her now and I haven't seen any flakes since the 2nd oil change. This is the 5th time I've changed the oil and I've been using M1 5W30 for the last 12K miles. As an experiment I grabbed a magnet and stuck it down in the old oil and found some very tiny debris (metallic dust)... I'm assuming the motor is still breaking in and this is normal but it has me scratching my head... I wish I would've had it analyzed.
#2
I just changed mine for the first time (3k miles) tonight and didn't notice anything on the drain plug at all. Is the drain plug magnetic? It just looked like a plain old bolt (the gasket was stuck to it pretty good though).
My GMC has a little magnetic nub on the end of the drain plug. I change the oil in it every 2K miles and there's always a bit of black paste (very fine metal shavings) on the drain plug. In fact, every vehicle I've ever owned with a magnetic plug has had the same thing, so I'd be inclined to say yours is normal.
My GMC has a little magnetic nub on the end of the drain plug. I change the oil in it every 2K miles and there's always a bit of black paste (very fine metal shavings) on the drain plug. In fact, every vehicle I've ever owned with a magnetic plug has had the same thing, so I'd be inclined to say yours is normal.
#3
Originally posted by EricM
I just changed mine for the first time (3k miles) tonight and didn't notice anything on the drain plug at all. Is the drain plug magnetic? It just looked like a plain old bolt (the gasket was stuck to it pretty good though).
My GMC has a little magnetic nub on the end of the drain plug. I change the oil in it every 2K miles and there's always a bit of black paste (very fine metal shavings) on the drain plug. In fact, every vehicle I've ever owned with a magnetic plug has had the same thing, so I'd be inclined to say yours is normal.
I just changed mine for the first time (3k miles) tonight and didn't notice anything on the drain plug at all. Is the drain plug magnetic? It just looked like a plain old bolt (the gasket was stuck to it pretty good though).
My GMC has a little magnetic nub on the end of the drain plug. I change the oil in it every 2K miles and there's always a bit of black paste (very fine metal shavings) on the drain plug. In fact, every vehicle I've ever owned with a magnetic plug has had the same thing, so I'd be inclined to say yours is normal.
Thanks,
Justin
#5
I've seen some strap on magnetic bands that go around the oil filter. They are powerful magnets and are supposed to trap and metallic particles. Can't comment on the effectivity though.... But is sounds like a good idea.
#6
Alan (HaveBlue) told me that he used a strainer to catch a few metal shards when he was changing his oil, so it sounds like it may be normal wear and tear. he said that once he changed to synthetic, the shards disappeared.
sounds like pretty convincing testimony to me . . .
creed
sounds like pretty convincing testimony to me . . .
creed
#7
Ummm,... metal flakes in your oil and you only have 17K on the truck? I had no idea that during normal wear and tear ther would be metal shavings,... I'd keep scratching your head bro,... I would take it to the dealer and put up a stink about it just so they have it on record that you did bring it to their attention this early in the trucks life so that just in case it was somthing bad they would know that there was somthing wrong from the start.
Trending Topics
#8
Originally posted by cstary
Alan (HaveBlue) told me that he used a strainer to catch a few metal shards when he was changing his oil, so it sounds like it may be normal wear and tear. he said that once he changed to synthetic, the shards disappeared.
sounds like pretty convincing testimony to me . . .
creed
Alan (HaveBlue) told me that he used a strainer to catch a few metal shards when he was changing his oil, so it sounds like it may be normal wear and tear. he said that once he changed to synthetic, the shards disappeared.
sounds like pretty convincing testimony to me . . .
creed
#9
Originally posted by overKILL
Ummm,... metal flakes in your oil and you only have 17K on the truck? I had no idea that during normal wear and tear ther would be metal shavings,... I'd keep scratching your head bro,... I would take it to the dealer and put up a stink about it just so they have it on record that you did bring it to their attention this early in the trucks life so that just in case it was somthing bad they would know that there was somthing wrong from the start.
Ummm,... metal flakes in your oil and you only have 17K on the truck? I had no idea that during normal wear and tear ther would be metal shavings,... I'd keep scratching your head bro,... I would take it to the dealer and put up a stink about it just so they have it on record that you did bring it to their attention this early in the trucks life so that just in case it was somthing bad they would know that there was somthing wrong from the start.
I never said they were shavings... They are very tiny flakes... This is very common on new motors.
Do you really think that your motor doesn't have any metallic particles floating around? I challenge you to find out by using a strong magnet on your next oil change. I think you will be surprised...
Wait until you change your rear diff fluid the first time.. You're going to freak out when you see that huge chunk of metal shard stuck to your drain plug..
#10
First,... I chamged my rear diff oil already and it was clean,... no chunks. Secondly,... you said flakes,... the first thing that came to mind is large pieces or shaving,... I have found metal in my eninge oil and in my tranny oil,... they were very tiny,... more like metal particals rather than flakes. No need to challenge me bro,...
#11
Hello,
I have seen oil that was indicating bad stuff in the motor. From your description, it sounds like that is just break-in debris. I don't know what you use to catch the oil in, but if you saw silver trails in your oil, then I would worry. Some of that paste probably was assembly lube as well.
Would you say that the last 17k miles were easy or hard miles? If they were easy, then your motor might not have knocked loose some of that break-in debris.
I wouldn't worry about it. If you constitently see silver trails in your oil then worry cuz that is probably bad seals.
Anyway, later!
Joseph
I have seen oil that was indicating bad stuff in the motor. From your description, it sounds like that is just break-in debris. I don't know what you use to catch the oil in, but if you saw silver trails in your oil, then I would worry. Some of that paste probably was assembly lube as well.
Would you say that the last 17k miles were easy or hard miles? If they were easy, then your motor might not have knocked loose some of that break-in debris.
I wouldn't worry about it. If you constitently see silver trails in your oil then worry cuz that is probably bad seals.
Anyway, later!
Joseph
Last edited by uwf; 11-12-2003 at 07:43 AM.
#13
Originally posted by overKILL
First,... I chamged my rear diff oil already and it was clean,... no chunks. Secondly,... you said flakes,... the first thing that came to mind is large pieces or shaving,... I have found metal in my eninge oil and in my tranny oil,... they were very tiny,... more like metal particals rather than flakes. No need to challenge me bro,...
First,... I chamged my rear diff oil already and it was clean,... no chunks. Secondly,... you said flakes,... the first thing that came to mind is large pieces or shaving,... I have found metal in my eninge oil and in my tranny oil,... they were very tiny,... more like metal particals rather than flakes. No need to challenge me bro,...
Secondly, you're one of the few people that haven't had a shard or two in their diff...
#14
Originally posted by uwf
Hello,
I have seen oil that was indicating bad stuff in the motor. From your description, it sounds like that is just break-in debris. I don't know what you use to catch the oil in, but if you saw silver trails in your oil, then I would worry. Some of that paste probably was assembly lube as well.
Would you say that the last 17k miles were easy or hard miles? If they were easy, then your motor might not have knocked loose some of that break-in debris.
I wouldn't worry about it. If you constitently see silver trails in your oil then worry cuz that is probably bad seals.
Anyway, later!
Joseph
Hello,
I have seen oil that was indicating bad stuff in the motor. From your description, it sounds like that is just break-in debris. I don't know what you use to catch the oil in, but if you saw silver trails in your oil, then I would worry. Some of that paste probably was assembly lube as well.
Would you say that the last 17k miles were easy or hard miles? If they were easy, then your motor might not have knocked loose some of that break-in debris.
I wouldn't worry about it. If you constitently see silver trails in your oil then worry cuz that is probably bad seals.
Anyway, later!
Joseph
#15
Last time I checked, aluminum wont stick to a magnet. Will Iron?
I assume the ring lands are made of steel, but how would the "bits" get past the seal? They would get burned up.
I assume the ring lands are made of steel, but how would the "bits" get past the seal? They would get burned up.
Last edited by rimpainter.com; 11-12-2003 at 11:45 AM.
#16
Originally posted by <96 Runner>
Last time I checked, aluminum wont stick to a magnet. Will Iron?
I assume the ring lands are made of steel, but how would the "bits" get past the seal? They would get burned up.
Last time I checked, aluminum wont stick to a magnet. Will Iron?
I assume the ring lands are made of steel, but how would the "bits" get past the seal? They would get burned up.
#19
Dude,
If you said that the last couple of thousands you were getting into her, then you probably completely seated the rings. I thought that 4.7L was all aluminum? I am pretty sure of that.
Later,
Joseph
If you said that the last couple of thousands you were getting into her, then you probably completely seated the rings. I thought that 4.7L was all aluminum? I am pretty sure of that.
Later,
Joseph
#20
Originally posted by <96 Runner>
Actually, the 3.4 is an iron block.
Actually, the 3.4 is an iron block.
Justin